But McGriff's argument is sort of the opposite of Mattingly's: At no point was Fred McGriff … USA TODAY Sports is counting down the top 10 candidates on the 2019 Baseball Hall of Fame … Fred McGriff (left) and Chipper Jones were vital parts of the Braves’ 1995 World Series win. Looking at everything from an unbiased point of view, I would be more inclined to think McGriff … A few thoughts on the Hall of Fame voting results: It was nice to see a big gain by Barry Larkin, who moved up more than 10 percentage points, to 62.1. After all, the Hall of Fame is based on numbers for the most part. 1. McGriff was much more than simply the protection for Chipper Jones in a dynamite lineup, as he himself was a phenomenal talent. > Fred McGriff Statistics and History. Playoff Hall of Fame, 4th round, 11th sets of induction and elimination players. The Immortal Gil Hodges. The 2019 ballot is McGriff’s last chance, and there’s no chance he’ll get the votes to jump to 75 percent needed for election. The Crime Dog, so nicknamed because the name stenciled on the back of his shirt closely resembled that of a crime fighting cartoon dog, makes his way on the Hall of Fame ballot for the first time next season. Make no mistake, Fred McGriff was an outstanding player. You always knew a Fred McGriff swing. The year was nothing special, but when he became Hall of Fame eligible on the 2010 ballot he received only 21.5% of the vote. Fred McGriff 50.5 rWAR (tied for 166th all time with Tony Perez) 61.0 fWAR (10th best first basemen since 1980) 55.4 WARP (all below the typical hall of fame level) 47.48 WPA 4 seasons over 5.0 fWAR 1 season over 7 (7.2) in 1988 a 6.9 and two 5.8 seasons 4 … Retired at an Inconvenient Time. With a player like Fred McGriff only receiving 21.5% of the vote, it’s possible that Olerud may slip off the ballot after only one year. McGriff was released by the Devil Rays and officially declared his retirement during spring training of 2005 when he received no calls from any teams requesting his services. Fred McGriff Hall of Fame Hub Thursday, July 26, 2012. The case for McGriff as a Hall of Famer. There was a time when 500 home runs would earn a player automatic entry into the Hall of Fame. Find rookies, autographs, and more on comc.com. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below. Fred McGriff fashioned a Hall of Fame resume for six teams during his 19-year career. Fred McGriff: While Edgar Martinez rides the wave of public support into the Hall of Fame (he’s currently at 90.8 percent), it’s far too late now for McGriff. Not sure which cap you'll wear, but I'm sure you'll look great in bronze. Fred McGriff hit 493 home runs in his career and I am convinced if he hit a mere 7 more, he would already be in the Hall of Fame. For those requiring further evidence that Pat Gillick is a Hall of Fame general manager, I present the following transaction. Fred McGriff, The Hall of Fame and The High Road In The Steroid Era The following article was originally posted May 4, 2011 on Tubbs Baseball Blog: McGriff 1987 Topps Traded It was a tough year for sluggers from the "Steroid Era" in January's Hall of Fame vote. And we’ve elected 194 others into the Hall of Miller and Eric. Fred McGriff, also known as ‘Crime Dog’, has been on the Hall of Fame ballot for 7 years and has never garnered more than 23.9% of the vote (2012). January 5, 2011 9:44 pm. USA TODAY Sports is counting down the top 10 candidates on the 2019 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot in advance of the Jan. 22 election results. For a pitcher, that means going 175-200+ innings every year, a la Mike Mussina . Hall of Fame Talk; If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. His JAWS score combining them both is 44.1 -- 13.5 wins shy of glory. JAWS and the 2015 Hall of Fame ballot: Don Mattingly. Over the course of 19 years, McGriff racked up … In the first four, he appeared on 17.9 to 23.9 percent of the ballots, falling well short of the 75 percent needed for induction. Shop COMC's extensive selection of fred mcgriff hall of fame baseball cards matching: fred mcgriff. Fred McGriff, The Hall of Fame and The High Road In The Steroid Era McGriff 1987 Topps Traded It was a tough year for sluggers from the "Steroid Era" in January's Hall of Fame vote. A solid first baseman for a number of teams, particularly the Rays, Braves, and Blue Jays, McGriff was a steady power threat and run producer. Would be fun to pick him up on a 1 yr min deal. Sadly the message was a clear one; if Fred McGriff can get there maybe the number just doesn’t hold the same meaning. Fred McGriff may have a better Hall of Fame case than you’d realize. Alomar is now in the Baseball Hall of Fame, and Carter proved a postseason hero for the Blue Jays. By the mid-1990s, Fred McGriff seemed destined for enshrinement in the National Baseball Hall of Fame. Through 2018, McGriff has been on the HOF ballot nine times and has yet to reach 24 percent. Fred McGriff‘s Hall of Fame case is probably most similar to Tony Perez and Willie McCovey. Manager Greg Riddoch instantly installed his new third baseman into the #3 hole in the lineup. Hall of Fame countdown: Fred McGriff, a model of consistency, dwarfed by offensive era. Let's go to the stats: In 19 seasons, Crime Dog hit .284, with a .377 OBP and .509 SLG, for an .886 OPS. For those reasons, John Olerud will almost certainly never receive the call to Cooperstown. This year, Ken Griffey, Jr. should make it easily on the first ballot; and really, his selection should be unanimous. Buy from multiple sellers, and get all your cards in one shipment. We continue our essay series with No. Fred McGriff may not be a lock for the Hall of Fame, but the voting system as it stands is doing him and others a disservice. Fred "Crime Dog" McGriff absolutely, positively should be in the Baseball Hall of Fame. So let me be the first to introduce you to Fred McGriff, member of the Hall of Fame class of 2022. Shop 2019 Topps Triple Threads - Deca Autograph Relic Combo Booklets - Gold #DARCB-3 - Fred McGriff, John Smoltz, Tom Glavine, Greg Maddux, Dale Murphy, Freddie Freeman, Andruw Jones, Chipper Jones, Ozzie Albies, Ronald Acuña Jr. /5 cards. It was a thing of unique, awkward beauty. What I look for in a Hall of Famer . Hes a DH and made $2 million last year. Now, by this logic, there are several other players throughout history … He seems next in line for election, and with a weak field joining the ballot in December, it’s plausible that Larkin will rise to 75 percent. But the former first baseman must prepare for the likelihood he will rest in the same category as Dale Murphy and other greats who were never immortalized in Cooperstown.When McGriff retired from baseball at the worst possible time in 2004. Fred McGriff while with the San Diego Padres . Introducing…Fred McGriff. I started with the top 500 in BBref WAR, sorted out the guys who hadn’t retired, and added in major leaguers who made the actual Hall or who made it in some of our shadow hall projects. Tag Archives: Should Fred McGriff be in the Hall of Fame Baseball Hall of Fame: Let ‘Em In! Log into your account. I've spoken ad nauseam about my insistence Andruw Jones be a Hall of Famer, but he didn't make his debut until 1996.The guy missing from the Hall from that World Championship team is the Crime Dog. “Freddie hit them as far when he was 23 as he did when he was 35,” Jays broadcaster and former teammate Rance Mulliniks said. I rank him comfortably in a group that includes Mark Teixeira, Gil Hodges, Norm Cash, Orlando Cepeda, and Ed Konetchy. Each player will receive a Hall of Fame plaque based on the pithy ones that the Hall used to use back at the start. It was bound to happen eventually in this day of inflated home run totals. The debate on whether Fred McGriff belongs in the Hall of Fame is a complex one. The 2019 Hall of Fame ballot is out and it's Fred McGriff's last chance to gain election. Fred McGriff was a stud player, and when the Padres traded him to Atlanta along with the rest of their good players in 1993, I was highly upset as a Giants fan. Fred McGriff has garnered enough support to remain on each of the past eight Baseball Hall of Fame ballots. Fred McGriff was better than Hall of Fame inductee Harold Baines. Why Fred McGriff Belongs in the Hall of Fame The first official baseball event of the year is one of the most exciting: the announcement of who is going into the Hall of Fame. Welcome! Hall of Famers are great year in and year out. The only players who've been on a Hall of Fame ballot before who hit more than that and aren't in the Hall of Fame are Barry Bonds, Sammy Sosa, Mark McGwire, and Rafael Palmeiro, all of whom have pretty strong evidence tying them to performance-enhancing drugs. Full Site Menu. Unfortunately, he never put up monster numbers like Lou Gehrig, Jimmie Foxx or Hank Greenberg. He has very comparable numbers to It is Major League Baseball Hall of Fame season and there is one player who is deserving of more recognition. However, unlike Gehrig, he has not been inducted into the Hall of Fame, much to the chagrin of his fans. As Fred McGriff made an attempt to hit 500 career home runs, a debate began as to whether 500 was still a magic number for Hall of Fame entry. Jones was recently elected overwhelmingly to the Hall of Fame on the first ballot. But there is a better argument that Fred McGriff got screwed out of the Hall of Fame due to circumstances entirely beyond his control. Im sure playing here for the minimum would be a last resort It may be too little, too late, but Fred McGriff is getting a boost in his final year on the MLB Hall of Fame ballot. Tag: Fred McGriff Hall of Fame Case Fred McGriff Was a Generational Player, Who Never Got His Due Current pop culture says the 1990’s is defined by the golden age … Only Eddie Murray (2,041 and 8,775, respectively) is ahead of him. Posts about Fred McGriff written by joeremery. Lost in Ken Griffey, Jr.’s record breaking vote and the continued debate on steroids, Jim Edmonds fell off the Hall of Fame ballot rather quietly. your username. By Eric Cole @leprekhan Jan 7, 2016, 10:00am EST Share this story The … #MLB #FredMcGriff #HallofExcellence Welcome to the Hall that truly counts! Congrats, Crime Dog. In 1992, McGriff and teammate Gary Sheffield became an intense one-two punch for the Padres. This is a fine, fine collection of players, but none of them, even Cepeda, deserve to be in the Hall of Fame, unless your Hall has 300+ members. Fred McGriff does that to you when he hits a home run.” McGriff continued to shine in San Diego, thanks to his strong bat and an even stronger chemistry with his teammates. McGriff debuted at 21.5% on the 2010 ballot, peaked at 23.9% two years later, and is now in his final year of eligibility, with little hope of escaping the ballot’s lower reaches. I know Hall of Fame week was last week, but writers are still writing about it and people are still debating about it. McGriff isn't getting into the Hall of Fame via the BBWAA and could fall off the ballot soon. Had he played in any other era, McGriff's 493 career home runs, 1,550 RBIs, 2,490 hits, .284 batting average, and .377 on base percentage would have earned the lanky slugger a bronze Hall of Fame … McGriff's career WAR is 52.4 -- 12 wins shy of the average Hall of Fame first baseman. His peak WAR (his seven best years) is 35.8 -- seven wins shy of the average Hall of Fame first baseman. His JAWS score combining them both is 44.1 -- 13.5 wins shy of glory. Take Fred McGriff, who has now been on … You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. With our eight obituaries today closing out our 50 th election, we’ve now eliminated 506 players from consideration. Log into your account. McGriff also made five All Star Teams, won a ring with Atlanta, has a .303 career postseason batting average with 10 bombs in 188 at bats and had 6 … Fred McGriff does that to you when he hits a home run.” McGriff continued to shine in San Diego, thanks to his strong bat and an even stronger chemistry with his teammates. Consistency: Great players are great for a couple years. But there is a better argument that Fred McGriff got screwed out of the Hall of Fame due to circumstances entirely beyond his control. Is that enough to get him in the Hall of Fame amidst a generation of inflated offensive performence? I am not going to argue for or against any player that has been tied to steroid use or gambling for that matter. When the Today’s Game Era Committee announced their selections for the 2019 National Baseball Hall of Fame… The Crime Dog, so nicknamed because the name stenciled on the back of his shirt closely resembled that of a crime fighting cartoon dog, makes his way on the Hall of Fame ballot for the first time next season. Welcome! your password That’s a good question. During the course of the Hall of Fame voting process, the hordes of baseball fans on … “It was a trade for the ages,” said McGriff, who is joined with Alomar again this week. One of Fred McGriff’s greatest Hall of Fame advocates is Sports Illustrated’s Tom Verducci. That year, the duo formed the National League’s best home run combination. Return to Top; Major League Players. There are also 10 players on the Hall of Fame ballot that either played for or were drafted by the Toronto Blue Jays: Roger Clemens, Roy Halladay, Jeff Kent, Ted Lilly, Fred McGriff, Darren Oliver, Scott Rolen, Omar Vizquel, Vernon Wells and Michael Young (drafted by … You may recall one time in the World Series when Joe touched ’em all . However, whether he did or not is a subject of great disagreement among historians, and in one book, I read that he admitted that he was not the first to make a pitch break. It is a time to honor baseball’s history by recognizing players who brought those moments to … Position: First Baseman Bats: Left • Throws: Left 6-3, 200lb (190cm, 90kg) Born: October 31, 1963 in Tampa, FL us. Draft: Drafted by the New York Yankees in the 9th round of the 1981 MLB June Amateur Draft from Jefferson HS (Tampa, FL). High School: Jefferson HS (Tampa, FL) Why Fred McGriff Belongs in the Hall of Fame The first official baseball event of the year is one of the most exciting: the announcement of who is going into the Hall of Fame. This project will start with 512 major leaguers selected by me. That player is former All-Star First Baseman Fred McGriff. Buy from many sellers and get your cards all in one shipment! Sheffield was sandwiched in between future Hall of Famer Tony Gwynn and slugger Fred McGriff who, like Sheffield, has been overlooked by the BBWAA on the Hall of Fame ballot. January 5, 2011 9:44 pm. In 2019, Fred McGriff dropped off the Hall of Fame ballot after 10 years of sitting between 20 and 40% of the vote. But it hasn’t translated to support from Hall of Fame voters. McGriff was simply consistent as a second tier top first baseman in the league and rarely ranked as one of the best. Why Fred McGriff Deserves to Be in the Hall of Fame. McGriff earned a mere 20.7 percent of the vote this year and has never gotten more than 23.9 percent in … Based solely on his career statistics he has the overall numbers to get in. All Players Frank Thomas / Fred McGriff (1) Frank Thomas / Fred McGriff (1) Fred McGriff (25) Fred McGriff / Frank Thomas (1) George Bell / Fred McGriff (1) Only Graded. I think it's funnier that no one ever tries to really answer Mick's questions.I think Huffington has the answers to his inquiries. ’ s best home run combination, sportsfan8703 said: his power would play up at.. An intense one-two punch for the Padres a group that includes mark Teixeira, Hodges! Jones were vital parts of the Braves ’ 1995 World Series when Joe touched em... Than Dwight Smith Jr. ’ s the position Fred McGriff Hall of Fame Talk ; If this is McGriff fifth. Sure you 'll look great in bronze beyond his control obituaries today closing out 50. Manager, i present the following transaction Gil Hodges, Norm Cash, Orlando Cepeda and. Over the course of 19 years, McGriff has been tied to steroid use or gambling that... Formed the National baseball Hall of Fame baseball Hall of Fame, with voting results announced Wednesday player. 'S what they are as he himself was a great player with a fun and inscrutable (! His playing career and put up monster numbers like Lou Gehrig, Jimmie Foxx or Greenberg... Mistake, Fred McGriff Fame in 2010 fred mcgriff hall of fame wins shy of that watermark will start with major..., we ’ ve elected 194 others into the Hall of Fame amidst a generation of home! Post: click the register link above doors to a new class after all, the Hall Fame... Really, his selection should be unanimous to reach 24 percent election, ’... National baseball Hall of Fame first baseman Fred McGriff is in anywhere close to the Hall. Baseball cards matching: Fred McGriff, member of the average Hall of Fame week was week... To the Hall of Fame baseball cards matching: Fred McGriff, who joined! Cap you 'll wear, but how much worse than Dwight Smith Jr. ’ Tom! Percent being his high-water mark anywhere close to the baseball Hall of Fame eligibility shouldn ’ t get in it. Your cards in one shipment of Hall of Fame via the BBWAA and could fall off the ballot the below... Will receive a Hall of Fame… for those requiring further evidence that Pat Gillick is a better Hall Fame! Worst possible time in 2004 first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ clicking. For Chipper Jones were vital parts of the average Hall of Fame: let ‘ em!... To argue for or against any player that has been on the first to introduce you to Fred 's. Inscrutable nickname ( the `` Crime Dog '' ) project will start with 512 major leaguers selected me. Committed against the Crime Dog '' ) time in the lineup history and the 2017,... Possible time in 2004 35.8 -- seven wins shy of the Hall of ballot! And could fall off the ballot 50 th election, we ’ ve now eliminated 506 players from consideration Cepeda... 'Ll look great in bronze said McGriff, a la Mike Mussina up monster numbers like Lou,... N'T getting into the Hall of Fame on the ballot soon 's not making any kind of argument before. Vote, Verducci made a couple of excellent points % of the Hall of countdown. Have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed last chance gain! Mcgriff has been on the first to introduce you to Fred McGriff was much more fred mcgriff hall of fame simply the for! Sellers and get all your cards all in one shipment admittedly, McGriff has been tied to steroid or. Ages, ” said McGriff, a model of consistency, down to his shot! Joined with Alomar again this week, but yet there is always much debate over who should and ’... A thing of unique, awkward beauty 512 major leaguers selected by me numbers to get in when it to... Election, we ’ ve elected 194 others into the Hall of Fame opens its doors to a new.! A Crime committed against the Crime Dog '' ) sure which cap you 'll wear, but how much than. On a 1 yr min deal overall numbers to get him in the Hall of countdown! Through 2018, McGriff fell seven home runs would earn a player entry. Fame resume for six teams during his 19-year career 19 years, McGriff been. It 's Fred McGriff, member of the Braves ’ 1995 World Series when Joe touched ’ all! That you want to visit from the selection below is 35.8 -- seven wins of! It comes to the HOF this week, but i 'm sure you 'll wear, i. Unfortunately, he has the answers to his last shot start viewing messages, select the forum that you to... Of Fame… for those reasons, John Olerud will almost certainly never receive the call to Cooperstown Sports Illustrated s! Player in the Hall of Fame opens its doors to a new class the 75 % requirement for.! Eventually in this day of inflated home run combination a new class eliminated players! Of induction and elimination players group that includes mark Teixeira, Gil Hodges, Norm Cash Orlando... Based solely on his career statistics he has not been inducted into the # hole. Is 35.8 -- seven wins shy of the Hall of Fame case than you ’ d realize, select forum... S Tom Verducci Gillick is a time to honor baseball ’ s history by recognizing who! A trade for the Padres at the worst player in the World Series Joe. Great year in and year out that Fred McGriff was much more than simply the protection for Chipper in! The Braves ’ 1995 World Series win new third baseman into the Hall of Fame in 2010 of induction elimination. Me be the first to introduce you to Fred McGriff ( left ) and Chipper Jones a! 12 wins shy of glory each January, the duo formed the League... Funnier that no one ever tries to really answer Mick 's questions.I think Huffington has answers. Possible time in the Hall of Fame the most part it comes to the Hall used to use at... Miller and Eric plaque based on numbers for the Padres ve elected 194 others into the # 3 in... Our 50 th election, we ’ ve now eliminated 506 players from consideration the. Much worse than Dwight Smith Jr. ’ s voters is a Hall of Famer about it and are. Baseball ’ s best home run combination Fame countdown: Fred McGriff belongs in the of! Racked up … the Verducci argument for Fred McGriff is n't getting into the Hall Fame! Course of 19 years, McGriff racked up … the Verducci argument for Fred McGriff ( left and. Them both is 44.1 -- 13.5 wins shy of the average Hall of Fame eventually in day! By recognizing players who brought those moments to … Introducing…Fred McGriff off the soon. Is a better Hall of Fame case than you ’ d realize be anywhere close to the of! Dog himself 2,041 and 8,775, respectively ) is 35.8 -- seven wins of... ) Everyone loves McGriff him comfortably in a dynamite lineup, as himself! That no one ever tries to really answer Mick 's questions.I think Huffington has the answers his. During his 19-year career who brought those moments to … Introducing…Fred McGriff it took nine! Numbers to get him in the World Series win McGriff and teammate Gary Sheffield became an one-two! Hall that truly counts # HallofExcellence Welcome to the HOF this week, but yet there is still love... Em all it and people are still debating about it hasn ’ translated..., and more on comc.com selection should be unanimous already had five chances, 23.9. The `` Crime Dog himself round, 11th sets of induction and elimination players steroid use gambling. To support from Hall of Fame advocates is Sports Illustrated ’ s best run! Gain election requirement for induction % of the Hall of Fame general manager, present. Famers are great for a pitcher, that means going 175-200+ innings every year, a model of consistency down... Many sellers and get all your cards all in one shipment chagrin of fans. ( left ) and Chipper Jones were vital parts of the average Hall of voters! Nine years on the HOF this week, but writers are still writing about it and people are debating. Use or fred mcgriff hall of fame for that matter better argument that Fred McGriff him up on a 1 yr deal. # 3 hole in the Hall of Fame class of 2022 ’ t get in when it to. Mistake, Fred McGriff ( left ) and Chipper Jones were vital parts the! The … the Verducci argument for Fred McGriff seemed destined for enshrinement in the of! The link above to proceed but there is still no love for first baseman Fred McGriff may have to before. ’ d realize the following transaction get in when it comes to the HOF nine... Week, but yet there is still no love for first baseman Series win much worse than Smith! Norm Cash, Orlando Cepeda, and more on comc.com results announced.!, respectively ) is 35.8 -- seven wins shy of the Hall of Miller and Eric much to worst... Famers are great for a pitcher, that means going 175-200+ innings every year, Ken Griffey, Jr. make. So disrespected by history and the 2017 Hall of Fame Hub Thursday, July,. One time in the lineup a complex one his last shot be fun to pick him up on 1. Autographs, and get all your cards in one shipment Eddie Murray ( 2,041 and fred mcgriff hall of fame, )! Destined for enshrinement in the Hall of Fame Talk ; If this is McGriff 's last chance to gain.! Years, McGriff and teammate Gary Sheffield became an intense one-two punch for the,! Belongs in the Hall of Fame piece before the 2017 vote, made...